The Bruges Group spearheads the intellectual battle against the notion of "ever-closer Union" in Europe and, above all, against British involvement in a single European state.

How trust broke down in Britain

A Crisis of Trust

Stuart Wheeler 


The Bruges Group is pleased to announce the publication of A Crisis of Trust by Stuart Wheeler. It examines, in detail, the political culture that has grown up in Britain since our accession to the EU. And it shows how the expenses crisis is thoroughly the consequence of our suffering from a ‘Europeanised’ political class – with lavish expenses, PR and centralised party machines all playing their part.

A Crisis of Trust is a counter-blast to the conventional wisdom on the Westminster MPs expenses scandal. The speed with which the three main parties have fallen-in behind the recommendations of Sir Christopher Kelly’s Committee on Standards in Public Life is widely interpreted as proof that the next Parliament will be cleansed of the abuses that have brought our political life into contempt. If only it was this simple. For, as Stuart Wheeler demonstrates in this trenchantly argued critique, the new rules are based upon flawed logic and fundamental misconceptions. They will fail to restore our faith in our politicians because they misconstrue what the proper role of a modern MP should be.

It would be tempting to imagine that a change of government will solve these and many of the other problems that beset our public life. Unfortunately, we are likely to be disappointed by David Cameron, who for all his grandstanding on the subject, has shown an unerring ability to spot the main political advantage from the expenses scandal without demonstrating an appreciation of what needs to be done. His party’s formal submission to the Kelly Committee defended the payment of mortgage interest relief to MPs. The idea that the public purse is there to subsidise the private profit of politicians has been one of the most noxious aspects of this sorry saga. If the leader of the Opposition does not get that, he has not got very much.

We have seen how politicians, left to regulate their own pay and allowances, have behaved. Kelly has therefore concluded that they should relinquish their responsibility, with their pay and allowances being set by the Senior Salaries Review Board (SSRB) and administered by the Independent Parliamentary Standards Authority (IPSA). In reality, this divorce is not the path to reconciliation.

Stuart Wheeler shows how far from rescuing democracy, this approach abrogates it by insulating politicians from proper accountability. MPs have to have a say on their pay so that the public can have a say on their pay. MPs milked the system because there were able to keep their claims secret. It is full disclosure, not the existence of unaccountable bodies like the SSRB and the IPSA that will instil modest and appropriate claims at the taxpayer’s expense.

For Kelly’s approach risks producing the worst of both worlds – stripping politicians of being accountable to the electorate for their terms and conditions without having the means to meet out fitting punishment to those who break the rules. The IPSA’s main sanction will be to withhold future payments to MPs it finds have made improper claims until they have repaid their ill-gotten gains. Tough on crime? It is a chancer’s charter.

Indeed, it could hardly be otherwise. For the effectiveness of Kelly’s proposals are fatally undermined by rules that ensure that any regulatory regime dealing with parliament has to observe the convention that only the House of Commons can discipline its own members. This is simply wrong. Fraudulent expenses claims should be treated as theft plain and simple. As Wheeler points out, just as the church and the military have their own courts, so should Parliament. In addition to normal penalties for theft, this judicial body must have the power to expel guilty MPs from the Commons.

By contrast, the Kelly approach risks achieving precisely what it should avoid – the entrenchment of a political class, regulated like a wing of the civil service and retaining all the full-time employment rights including a “resettlement” (redundancy in any other language) payment when they lose their seats at a general election. Wheeler argues that we will all be the losers if legislators are further encouraged to remove themselves from the wider community. If an MP can be expected to take a second job running a government department, why can an MP be deemed ineligible from gaining any other form of experience?

What indeed are MPs for? Are they there to submit legislation to detailed scrutiny or behave like a one-stop-shop for constituents unhappy about the quality of service provided by their local council? In the past decade, the number of staff assisting MPs grew from 1,753 to 2,694 – and all this at a time when devolution within the UK and the transferral of powers beyond it to Brussels lightened the politicians’ responsibilities. Wheeler calls for an urgent re- examination into what MPs are at Westminster to do.

Wheeler calls for our MPs to be independent of their leaders. MPs subservient to their party machines, and dependent upon them for their place in the Commons, cannot be expected to argue in the national or local interest. A grievously flawed consensus – on Europe, on the environment and the on the economy – has been the direct consequence of this profound lack of independence.

A Crisis of Trust is an invaluable guide to what has gone wrong and how our shattered parliamentary institutions may yet be put right, written by one of Britain’s most successful and well-informed businessmen. It is essential reading at a time when the issues it addresses have never been in more urgent need of a workable solution.

Copies are free for members of the Bruges Group, and otherwise, £7.50

Click here to read the full book online


NEWSLETTER
 

Sign up for our mailing
list and receive our
latest news, comment
and events.


The EU’s attack on Britain’s most successful industry
The City of London in retreat
Professor Tim Congdon 

Debunking Major's Myths of the Eurosceptics
The Dispossessed, the Never-Possessed and the Bastards

But were afraid to ask
Everything you wanted to know about the EU

Re-joining EFTA as an alternative to membership of the European Union
The Norway Option
Dr Richard North 

What is the best option , or best options, for Britain trading with EU countries?
EFTA or EU? Qs & As
Hugo van Randwyck 

Montgomery and the Battle of the Bulge
Knife Edge

Rejecting the EU's regulatory instrument
Saying No to the Single Market
Ruth Lea 
Barry Legg 
Dr Andrew Lilico 
Ian Milne 
Professor David Myddelton 
Professor Jean-Jacques Rosa 

What a British Military Hero Can Teach Those Fighting Today's War on Terror
Montgomery and the First War on Terror

Divide and Conquer
British Regionalization

Amounts, safeguards and breaches in the dyke
The UK’s risks and exposure to the EIB and other European financial mechanisms
Bob Lyddon 

'Isolation' and inward investment
Does the EU’s Single Market Encourage FDI into the UK?
Michael Burrage 

Enlightened despotism is despotism nonetheless
National Interests and the European Union

The End of Imitative Europeanization?
The Eastern Partnership’s Troubles
Dr Andrey Karbovskiy 

To protect liberty we must preserve national sovereignty
Sovereignty and Liberty: An American Perspective

A viable alternative to EU membership
EFTA or the EU?
Hugo van Randwyck 

Why the Euro cannot survive with Germany at its centre
German Economic Policy and the Euro 1999 - 2010
Richard Conquest 

The stark economic facts as to why the UK should leave the EU
The Single Market and British Withdrawal
Ian Milne 

The Ideology of Anti-democratic Governance
European Union Power

The anti-democratic system by which we are governed
How EU Laws are Made

Comparing the EU and the US response to climate alarmism
A Lesson in Democracy
Jeremy Nieboer 

How trust broke down in Britain
A Crisis of Trust
Stuart Wheeler 

The EU and its attack on Britain’s most successful industry
The City of London Under Threat
Professor Tim Congdon 

The Cameron approach does further damage to Britain’s ‘broken politics’
Tory ‘renegotiation’ is a slogan not a policy
Gerald Frost 

The impact of European Union legislation on Britain’s railways
On the Wrong Track
John Petley 

The United Kingdom and the European Union
Our Fight for Democracy
John Strafford 

Why the EU’s climate alarmism is both mistaken and dangerous
Cool Thinking on Climate Change
Roger Helmer MEP 

Analysis of the potential disaster facing the eurozone
Is the euro Sustainable?
Richard Conquest 

EU recovery plan costs UK £25 billion
The EU’s Credibility Crunch: Creator of economic downturn, Impediment to recovery
Damon Lambert 

£106,117 Per Minute Scandal
How much does the European Union cost Britain? 2008
Gerard Batten MEP 

Corporate Tax Threat to the Economy
Costly, Complex and Counterproductive: The Case Against a Common Consolidated Corporate Tax Base
Damon Lambert 

Submitting to authority dressed as virtue
Are the British a Servile People? Idealism and the EU

The radical changes needed if we are to survive as a free people
The Costs of Regulation and How the EU Makes Them Worse
William Mason 

Galileo up-date
Black is White: Government deception and the Galileo project

Exposing the revived and renamed EU Constitution
A look at the Lisbon Treaty

Discussing European integration and Britain's special path in history
The Principles of British Foreign Policy
Philip Vander Elst 

Britain in the 21st Century
Lost Illusions: British Foreign Policy
Ian Milne 

EU costing Britain £60.1 billion per year
How much does the European Union cost Britain? 2007
Gerard Batten MEP 

How can we afford to stay in
How much does the European Union cost Britain? 2006
Gerard Batten MEP 

Micro guide # 3
Another slice of the Salami: How the European Criminal Code is being introduced by stealth

Alternatives to the EU #1
The Case for EFTA
Daniel Hannan MEP 

Alternatives to centralisation
Plan B For Europe: Lost Opportunities in the EU Constitution Debate

Micro guide # 2
The Corpse Bride

Micro guide #1
Can the EU be Reformed?

Exposing the facts, busting the myths
All you need to know about the EU

Europe's last chance
The Bottom Line

EU Constitution Briefing Paper # 06
Will the EU's Constitution Rescue its Currency?
Professor Tim Congdon 

Paper No. 47
Galileo: The Military and Political Dimensions
Dr Richard North 

A New World Order: What Role for Britain? #1
The Fate of Britain's National Interest

EU Constitution Briefing Paper # 05
Health and the Nation

EU Constitution Briefing Paper # 04
Criminal Justice and the draft Constitution
The Rt Hon. Oliver Letwin MP 

EU Constitution Briefing Paper # 03
Subsidiarity and the Illusion of Democratic Control
John Bercow MP 

EU Constitution Briefing Paper # 02
A Constitution to destroy Europe
Bill Jamieson 

EU Constitution Briefing Paper # 01
Giscard d'Estaing's "Constitution": Muddle and Danger Presented in Absurd Prolixity

Paper No. 46
Free Speech: The EU Version

Paper No. 45
Federalist Thought Control: The Brussels Propaganda Machine

Paper No. 44
Democracy in Crisis: The White Paper on European Governance
Nigel Farage MEP 

Paper No. 43
European Union and the Politics of Culture
Dr Cris Shore 

Paper No. 42
Britain and Europe: The Culture of Deceit
Christopher Booker 

Paper No. 41
Ultimate Vindication: The Spectator and Europe 1966-79
Thomas Teodorczuk 

Paper No. 40
William Hague's European Policy
Dr Martin Holmes 

Paper No. 39
The Myth of Europe
Russell Lewis 

Paper No. 38
Alien Thoughts: Reflections on Identity
Robert W Cahn 
Yahya El-Droubie 

Paper No. 37
The Bank that rules Europe? The ECB and Central Bank Independence
Mark Baimbridge 
Brian Burkitt 
Philip Whyman 

Paper No. 36
Conservative MEPs and the European People's Party: Time for Divorce
Jonathan Collett 

Paper No. 35
Franco–German Friendship and the Destination of Federalism
Dr Martin Holmes 

Paper No. 33
Aiming for the Heart of Europe: A Misguided Venture
John Bercow MP 

Paper No. 32
Britain's Economic Destiny: A Business Perspective
Sir Michael Edwardes 

Paper No. 31
Is Europe Ready for EMU? Theory, Evidence and Consequences
Mark Baimbridge 
Brian Burkitt 
Philip Whyman 

Paper No. 30
Reviewing Europe: Selected Book Reviews 1991 - 7
Dr Martin Holmes 

Paper No. 28
John Major and Europe: The Failure of a Policy 1990-7
Dr Martin Holmes 

Paper No. 26
Professor A.J.P. Taylor on Europe: The Historian Who Predicted the Future
Peter Oborne 

Paper No. 25
Godfather of the European Union: Altiero Spinelli
Lindsay Jenkins 

Paper No. 24
A Single European Currency: Why the United Kingdom must say 'No'
The Rt Hon. David Heathcoat-Amory MP 

Paper No. 23
The Conservative Conference & Euro-Sceptical Motions 1992-95

Paper No. 20
From Single Market to Single Currency: Evaluating Europe's Economic Experiment
Dr Martin Holmes 

Paper No. 17
The Conservative Party and Europe
Dr Martin Holmes 

Paper No. 34
Bruges Revisited
The Rt Hon. Baroness Thatcher LG, OM, FRS